Criminal Mischief in St. Johns County, Florida

383
Total Cases
64.0%
Guilty Rate
18.8%
Withheld Rate
4.4%
Dismissal Rate
1 year, 3 months
Avg Sentence

Based on 383 Criminal Mischief cases in St. Johns County (2023-2025), 64.0% resulted in a guilty finding, 18.8% had adjudication withheld, and 4.4% were dismissed. The average sentence for convicted defendants is 1 year, 3 months, with an average fine of $477.12. 19.1% of defendants retained private counsel while 52.0% used a public defender.

Facing Criminal Mischief charges in St. Johns County?

Outcome Breakdown

Guilty
64.0% (245)
Withheld
18.8% (72)
Diversion
12.0% (46)
Dismissed
4.4% (17)
Acquitted
0.0% (0)

Sentencing Breakdown

1 year, 3 months
Avg Sentence
2.6 months
Median Sentence
2.0 years
Avg Probation
$477.12
Avg Fine
11.2%
Prison Rate
46.0%
Jail Rate
Confinement Type Count Avg Sentence
County Jail 176 4.0 months
State Prison Facility 43 5.0 years

Counsel Analysis

199
Public Defender
79.4% guilty · 3.0% dismissed
73
Private Attorney
38.4% guilty · 0.0% dismissed
43
Conflict Counsel
86.0% guilty · 2.3% dismissed
11
Court Private or Assigned Counsel
72.7% guilty · 0.0% dismissed
8
Self or Unrepresented
25.0% guilty · 12.5% dismissed

Demographics

Demographic data reflects systemic patterns in the criminal justice system and should not be used to draw conclusions about any racial or ethnic group. Disparities may reflect differences in policing, prosecution, and socioeconomic factors rather than actual crime rates.

Race Cases Guilty Rate Dismissal Rate
White 242 55.0% 6.2%
Black 116 81.9% 0.9%

Age Distribution

18.3%
Under 21
24.5%
21-29
20.4%
30-39
22.2%
40-49
9.4%
50-59
5.2%
60+

Year-Over-Year Trends

Year Cases Guilty Rate Dismissal Rate Avg Sentence
2023 106 64.2% 6.6% 1 year, 5 months
2024 166 65.7% 4.8% 1 year, 6 months
2025 111 61.3% 1.8% 8.0 months

Charge Level Breakdown

Level Degree Cases
Misdemeanor First Degree 145
Felony Third Degree 129
Misdemeanor Second Degree 109

Related Charges in St. Johns County

Charge Cases Guilty Rate Dismissal Rate
Traffic Offense 7,840 36.5% 6.1%
Drug Possession 2,813 66.1% 2.3%
Other 2,071 67.0% 7.3%
Larceny / Theft 2,011 59.2% 3.8%
Battery 1,643 47.2% 3.5%
DUI 1,337 92.3% 4.6%
Trespassing 1,088 82.5% 4.0%
Resisting Officer 1,015 66.6% 3.0%

Need a Defense Attorney in St. Johns County?

Get matched with a local attorney who handles Criminal Mischief cases. Free, confidential, no obligation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the guilty rate for Criminal Mischief in St. Johns County?
The guilty rate is 64.0% based on 383 cases (2023-2025).
How often is adjudication withheld for Criminal Mischief in St. Johns County?
Adjudication is withheld in 18.8% of cases. This is a Florida-specific outcome where the court finds guilt but does not formally convict, allowing the defendant to avoid a conviction record under FL Statute 948.01.
What is the average sentence for Criminal Mischief in St. Johns County?
The average sentence is 1 year, 3 months, with an average fine of $477.12.
What percentage use a public defender vs private attorney?
52.0% of defendants use a public defender, while 19.1% retain private counsel.

About this data: Statistics are derived from FDLE Criminal Justice Data Transparency records for St. Johns County. "Guilty" includes all cases where the defendant was found guilty. "Adjudication withheld" is a Florida-specific disposition where guilt is found but the court withholds formal adjudication under FL Statute 948.01. "Dismissed" includes all cases dismissed by the court or prosecution.

Source: FDLE Criminal Justice Data Transparency · 383 cases · 2023-2025 · Data last updated March 2026