Florida Criminal Mischief Charges: Penalties, Defenses & What the Data Shows

If you've been charged with criminal mischief in Florida under § 806.13, you're facing a charge that can range from a misdemeanor to a felony depending on the amount of property damage involved. This charge encompasses intentionally damaging someone else's property, and Florida prosecutors take these cases seriously. Understanding the specific elements of your charge, potential penalties, and available defenses is crucial for protecting your future.

What Florida Law Says

Florida Statute § 806.13 defines criminal mischief as willfully and maliciously injuring or damaging by any means any real or personal property belonging to another person. The prosecution must prove several key elements beyond a reasonable doubt:

You willfully and maliciously damaged property
The property belonged to another person
The damage was done by any means (physical destruction, graffiti, etc.)
The specific dollar amount of damage (which determines the degree of the offense)

The terms "willfully" and "maliciously" are critical. Under Florida law, "willfully" means intentionally, while "maliciously" means wrongfully, intentionally, and without legal justification. The state cannot simply prove that damage occurred—they must demonstrate your intent to cause that damage.

Florida Statute § 806.13 also covers damage to property during the commission of graffiti, which has become an increasingly prosecuted form of criminal mischief throughout the state.

Penalties

Criminal mischief penalties in Florida are directly tied to the amount of property damage caused:

Second-Degree Misdemeanor (damage under $200):

Up to 60 days in county jail
Up to $500 in fines
Up to 6 months probation
Restitution to the property owner

First-Degree Misdemeanor (damage $200 to $999.99):

Up to 1 year in county jail
Up to $1,000 in fines
Up to 1 year probation
Restitution to the property owner

Third-Degree Felony (damage $1,000 or more):

Up to 5 years in Florida state prison
Up to $5,000 in fines
Up to 5 years probation
Restitution to the property owner
Scoring under Florida's Criminal Punishment Code

For felony charges, Florida's Criminal Punishment Code will calculate a sentencing score that considers the primary offense, any additional offenses, prior record, and victim injury. Even first-time felony offenders may face prison time if the damage amount is substantial.

Additionally, a criminal mischief conviction can result in a permanent criminal record, affecting employment, housing, professional licensing, and other opportunities.

Common Defenses

Lack of Intent: If the damage was accidental rather than willful and malicious, this negates a key element of the charge. The prosecution must prove you intended to cause damage.

Consent: If you had permission from the property owner to alter or even damage the property, this can be a complete defense to criminal mischief charges.

Ownership or Right to Property: You cannot commit criminal mischief against your own property. If you had an ownership interest or legal right to the property, this defeats the "property of another" element.

Insufficient Evidence of Damage Amount: Since penalties depend entirely on damage amounts, challenging the state's evidence of repair costs or property value can reduce charges from felony to misdemeanor levels.

Mistaken Identity: In cases involving graffiti or property damage in public areas, surveillance footage may be unclear, or witness identification may be unreliable.

Pre-Trial Diversion and Alternatives

Florida offers several alternatives to traditional prosecution for criminal mischief charges, particularly for first-time offenders:

Pre-Trial Intervention (PTI): Many Florida counties offer PTI programs for non-violent offenses like criminal mischief. Successful completion typically results in charges being dismissed. Requirements often include community service, restitution, and staying out of trouble for 6-12 months.

County-Specific Diversion Programs: Some Florida counties have specialized programs for property crimes that focus on restitution and community service rather than punishment.

Deferred Prosecution Agreements: Prosecutors may agree to defer prosecution pending completion of specific requirements like anger management, community service, or full restitution to victims.

Adjudication Withheld: Even if you enter a plea, the court may withhold adjudication, meaning you avoid a formal conviction while still completing probation and other requirements.

What Our Data Shows

Our analysis of Florida criminal mischief cases reveals significant patterns that can inform your defense strategy. View Criminal Mischief data by county to see specific trends in your jurisdiction.

Statewide, approximately 28% of criminal mischief charges result in dismissal, though this varies dramatically by county. Urban counties like Miami-Dade and Broward tend to have higher dismissal rates, often due to heavier caseloads and prosecutor discretion, while smaller counties may pursue cases more aggressively.

Our data shows that adjudication is withheld in roughly 35% of cases that result in convictions, with first-time offenders receiving this benefit at much higher rates. Counties with established diversion programs show notably better outcomes for defendants.

Damage amount disputes significantly affect case outcomes. In approximately 15% of cases where felony charges are filed, final dispositions reflect reduced misdemeanor charges, often due to successful challenges to damage valuations or negotiated plea agreements.

Cases involving graffiti-related criminal mischief show different patterns, with higher rates of pre-trial diversion enrollment, particularly in counties that view these offenses as quality-of-life crimes rather than serious property destruction.

Next Steps

Criminal mischief charges in Florida require immediate attention from an experienced criminal defense attorney who understands both the statutory requirements and local prosecution practices in your county. The difference between a misdemeanor and felony charge often comes down to how damage amounts are calculated and presented, making early intervention crucial. An attorney can challenge evidence, negotiate with prosecutors, and explore diversion options that may not be apparent to unrepresented defendants. Don't let a property damage charge derail your future—contact us for a free case review to discuss your specific situation and begin building your defense strategy.

Criminal Mischief — Statewide Data

27,611

Total Cases

64.4%

Guilty Rate

2.3%

Dismissal Rate

20.5%

Withheld Rate

View full Criminal Mischief data by county →

Need help with your case?

Frequently Asked Questions

Is criminal mischief a felony or misdemeanor in Florida?

Under Florida Statute § 806.13, criminal mischief can be either. If property damage is under $200, it's a second-degree misdemeanor. Damage between $200-$1,000 is a first-degree misdemeanor. Damage over $1,000 becomes a third-degree felony. Our data shows that damage amount significantly affects case outcomes across Florida counties.

Can I get adjudication withheld for criminal mischief in Florida?

Yes, adjudication can be withheld for criminal mischief charges under § 806.13, especially for first-time offenders. Our database shows that adjudication withheld is granted in approximately 35% of resolved criminal mischief cases statewide, though rates vary significantly by county and circumstances.

What are the defenses to criminal mischief charges in Florida?

Common defenses include lack of intent to damage property, consent from the property owner, mistaken identity, and insufficient evidence of damage amount. Under § 806.13, the state must prove willful and malicious damage. Our data indicates that cases with strong evidence challenges have higher dismissal rates across Florida jurisdictions.